Check your stars first
Before you pay a local SEO agency a dime, and before the first sales meeting.
Synup studied 53,900 Google results pages this year and found a local pack on 91.4% of desktop searches. Every one of those desktop packs held exactly 3 businesses. That's the prize an agency is paid to win, one of 3 slots.
But BrightLocal's 2026 survey of 1,002 adults found 31% of people will only use a business rated 4.5 stars or higher. A year earlier it was 17%. And 41% say they always read the reviews, up from 29%.
So those 3 slots get sorted by stars before anyone clicks.
Say you run a heating company in Greensburg with a 4.1, and an agency gets you into the pack. A homeowner with a dead furnace sees you next to a 4.7 and a 4.8, and calls the 4.8.
You paid to be seen and skipped.
No agency can fix that part, because reviews are your job and most owners don't do it.
- Ask every customer. That means every finished job and every sale, not just the people who smiled on the way out. Picking who gets asked only hides the problem.
- Keep the ask neutral. "Would you leave us a review?" works, and "Would you leave us 5 stars?" doesn't. Birdeye's 2026 rundown of Google Business Profile rules notes Google now expects requests to stay neutral.
Once the rating holds up, hire help for the rest. Rankings, listings and the technical stuff are where paid local SEO work earns its money, but not before.
Grab your phone tonight, open Google, search your business by name and read two things, your star rating and the date of your newest review.
Under 4.5, start asking before you start paying.
Keep reading
Ready to be found by both humans and AI?
See exactly how ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Google AI describe your business today.
Get your free AI Citation Report